Everyone in tech thinks everyone else in tech is a liar or an idiot
I have many deeply techie friends: people who work, live, and breathe tech. They aren’t tech bros; they’re the real deal. They’re accomplished professionals—and when it comes to technology, they’re usually right.
But if you asked them, they’d say all the others are idiots at best, liars at worst. And while the tech industry has always been contentious about some things (tabs vs spaces, emacs vs vi), this kind of in-fighting animosity (split mostly along the lines of AI adoption) is largely a new development.
Hating everyone is exhausting
Never before have I blocked so many people on social media for fundamentally petty reasons. If I see someone being Wrong Enough about something I know a lot about, I just block them. I don’t want them polluting my feed with misinformation, so now, they’re gone.
And that’s included quite a few people that I know and I respect. Everyone is just getting different information now—and they have to pick what they believe in somewhat arbitrarily. People are living inside of sectors that are quite niche and believing that everything they see can be extrapolated to the world at large.
The industry is diverging in capricious ways such that one person's reality may not be your own.
I’m not immune from this. No one is; that’s the point.
People are in silos. The tech industry is being rebuilt from the ground up, which means that people are building what tech means to them differently. Small companies, mid-sized enterprises, and big tech are all diverging regarding architecture and best practice. Department to department, person to person, roles and processes are shifting.
But that doesn’t mean reality doesn’t exist altogether. When it comes to technology, a lot of people are just wrong now. They’re confidently wrong because they’ve read a dozen AI blogs; they’re confidently wrong because they have a very small snapshot of a broader industry; they’re confidently wrong because Claude told them.
And they’re angry because they think other people are just lying.
But really there are just a bunch of liars and idiots
The problem is that there really are a bunch of liars and idiots now producing large swathes of tech content at a rate that very well outpaces expertise. This is part of what’s making it impossible to derive what’s actually going on; it’s why people who used to be respected voices are getting misled.
When the AI boom started, I saw a bunch of teens and 20-year-olds transform into the “voice of AI” virtually overnight. I watched them do this; over the course of a handful of weeks, they became authoritative “AI builders” and “industry insiders.”
Many of them are either early career or not in the tech industry at all.
To the average person, they are absolutely indistinguishable from a domain expert. To domain experts, they’re still convincing; anyone can spin up an impressive sounding bio and say something that is adjacent to the truth.
And now they’re getting real jobs in the industry with little more experience than a Twitter following; they are in industry now, with no real knowledge to speak of.
So, we have a situation in which our industry has been seeded by these neoprofessionals and nonprofessionals, all of whom have highly technical opinions and who have a vested interest in producing content and opinions at a very rapid clip. At the same time, we have an industry that is going through change at a rapid clip, such that no one is seeing the same things with their own eyes.
It's not a surprise this is confusing the situation.
Our trust in others is degrading
The consequence of this is that many of us can no longer trust the truth even when it’s right in front of our eyes. Instead, we are collapsing into a form of conspiracy thinking. When everything seems random and arbitrary, we start drawing patterns from what is there—these patterns are not necessarily real, they just happen.
And the loudest voices will dominate. If everyone thinks one thing, that might as well be true.
Consider, of course, the recent tech infrastructure failures. To someone outside of tech, there’s every reason for this to look like a coordinated external attack. We’ve had attacks before. They all happened one after the other. And they brought down massive systems that were previously extremely stable. There is every reason to think that these are coordinated attacks.
But they probably aren’t.
Most people inside of tech know that systems are currently a house of cards. We are in a transitional state and still figuring out and building processes. With rampant AI automation occurring, systems are becoming far more unpredictable. This unpredictability cascades into unrelated failures. Combine this with the media highlighting these failures more frequently, and you have what appears to be a coordinated attack.
At the same time, someone in tech who does not see this happening—who, for example, works for a company that pushes back against AI, or who works in a highly regulated industry—will still likely think it’s a coordinated attack and that people who are blaming AI acceleration are simply scapegoating and lying. A solo developer who works competently with AI in a controlled infrastructure will push back and say that AI cannot be the problem here, because companies would never be so irresponsible.
And all these professionals will think that the others are lying, because everyone is now used to being lied to and because the worlds in which they live are substantially divergent.
We can’t fight misinformation without information
There’s a point at which skepticism actually becomes an albatross hung around your neck. I’m experiencing this now. My first reaction to just about anything that falls outside of my realm of understanding is now “well, they’re lying.” And, I’ll be honest—I still think that’s true more often than not, due to bots and influencers. That is part of the problem, if not the whole of the problem.
People who are tired of being lied to are now reacting with skepticism and derision first, before asking questions. But as we become more resistant to new information, we push ourselves further away from the truth—however scarce.
My friends all think that the others are idiots. And that’s probably accurate, to some degree; everyone is an idiot about something. But it’s also because there are few real answers.
When people argue about what AI can and can’t do, the argument is often rendered irrelevant because “what AI can do” has changed from the beginning of the sentence. Likewise, when people argue about what is causing major infrastructure issues, we are often arguing from a point of limited visibility—we can know what is likely, we can’t know what is really true.
And it’s possible we need to be more open to that ambiguity and that lack of certainty, at least for a while. But it's also possible that we are simply in a crisis of authority and expertise—a broader problem that will become worse before it gets better.